Christmas is a time for joy, warmth, and family gatherings, and Christmas movies play a significant role in amplifying these festive feelings. They provide a shared experience that brings people together, evoking memories of past holidays and creating new traditions. From heartwarming tales of love and redemption to hilarious comedies that capture the chaos of the season, the best Christmas films have a unique ability to resonate with audiences of all ages. These movies often become cherished classics, eagerly anticipated each year, and serve as a backdrop for countless holiday celebrations.
✕ Remove Ads
However, not all Christmas films manage to capture the magic and spirit that make the season so special. While many succeed in delivering memorable stories and endearing characters, some fall short, leaving viewers disappointed and critics unimpressed. The reasons behind these missteps vary widely. Poor storytelling can result in convoluted plots that fail to engage or emotionally connect with the audience. Subpar acting may lead to unconvincing performances that undermine the film’s intended impact. From Hallmark movie disappointments to misguided theatrical releases, these films simply miss the mark in embodying the true essence of the holiday season.
10 The Christmas Card
A Painfully Generic Christmas Romance Film In An Already Saturated Market
Your Rating
10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10
Your comment has not been saved
The Christmas Card Release Date December 2, 2006 Cast Alice Evans , John Newton , Edward Asner Main Genre Romance
✕ Remove Ads
The Christmas Card attempts to deliver a heartfelt holiday story but falls short of expectations. The film aims to provide a warm, uplifting narrative. However, the execution leaves much to be desired. The plot follows a soldier who receives a Christmas card from a stranger and decides to visit her hometown, leading to a romance. While the premise is intriguing, the predictable storyline and overly sentimental moments feel stale.
The chemistry in
The Christmas Card
between the leads feels forced, and the supporting characters lack depth, making the emotional highs feel unearned.
Fans of Hallmark might find some enjoyment in the movie’s attempt to create a feel-good Christmas story, but The Christmas Card fails to stand out among countless holiday romances. The chemistry in The Christmas Card between the leads feels forced, and the supporting characters lack depth, making the emotional highs feel unearned. Reliance on clichés and formulaic plot points renders the film forgettable in a sea of similar offerings. Even with its heartwarming themes, the movie struggles to resonate, leaving viewers searching for more compelling holiday stories.
✕ Remove Ads
9 Red One
An Uninspired Box-Office Fail
Red One PG-13ActionAdventureComedyFantasy
Director Jake Kasdan Release Date November 15, 2024 Writers Chris Morgan , Hiram Garcia Cast Dwayne Johnson , Chris Evans , J.K. Simmons , Lucy Liu , Kiernan Shipka , Bonnie Hunt , Kristofer Hivju , Nick Kroll , Wesley Kimmel , Mary Elizabeth Ellis , Wyatt Hunt , Lanz Duffy , Marc Evan Jackson , Ashleigh Domangue , Cody Easterbrook , Jon Rudnitsky , Morla Gorrondona , Jenna Kanell , Rod Maxwell , Fedor Steer , Octavia Grace , Matthew Zuk , Cora Kass , Ahmad Ghafouri , Jeff Chase Character(s) Callum Drift , Jack O’Malley , Santa Claus , Zoe , Gryla , Mrs. Claus , Krampus , Ted , Dylan , Olivia , Young Jack O’Malley , Gene , Uncle Rick , Jamie Hummiston , HIT Instructor , Beef Stew , Ogre Gryla , Krampus Guest , Stage Manager , Cyclops Runtime 123 Minutes Main Genre Action YouTube Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7l3hfD74X-4 Expand
Despite its star-studded cast featuring Dwayne Johnson and Chris Evans, critics agreed that Red One falls short as a holiday action-comedy. The film attempts to blend festive magic with high-octane adventure but suffers from a lack of cohesive direction and charm. One of the primary issues is its identity crisis; Red One tries to cater to both adults and children, resulting in a wandering tone that fails to fully engage either audience. Consequently, the movie holds a somewhat unimpressive 31% score on Rotten Tomatoes.
✕ Remove Ads
The film’s world-building and mythology are commendable, showcasing creative art design and imaginative sets. However, this visual appeal isn’t enough to compensate for the weak script and flat character development. Dwayne Johnson’s performance as Callum Drift is surprisingly joyless, lacking the charismatic energy audiences have come to expect from him. His character feels one-dimensional, and the dynamic between Johnson and Evans in Red One doesn’t deliver the comedic or emotional impact it aims for.
Related Red One Review: Dwayne Johnson’s Joyless Dud Is An Epic Christmess That Takes Itself Way Too Seriously
Big name stars collide for a festive adventure that’s big on effects and spectacle but curiously lacks any of the charm of the holidays.
Posts2
The film’s villain is also underwhelming, with motivations and backstory that aren’t sufficiently explored, leaving the central conflict feeling shallow. Additionally, the dialogue often misses the mark, sometimes bordering on cliché and lacking the wit necessary for a successful action-comedy. Despite a substantial budget evident in its special effects and production design, Red One doesn’t translate its resources into a compelling narrative. The excessive focus on spectacle over substance results in a movie that feels hollow; the opposite of the magic a Christmas movie should have.
✕ Remove Ads
8 Jingle All The Way 2
Fun But Overly Dilapidated
Your Rating
10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10
Your comment has not been saved
Jingle All the Way 2 PG Director Alex Zamm Release Date December 2, 2014 Writers Stephen Mazur , William Robertson , Alex Zamm Cast Larry the Cable Guy , Kennedi Clements , Brian Stepanek , Lindsay Maxwell , David Milchard , Meredith McGeachie Runtime 93 minutes
Jingle All The Way 2 attempts to revive the magic of the original but fails to capture the same chaotic humor and heartfelt moments. Starring Larry the Cable Guy instead of Arnold Schwarzenegger, the sequel feels like a hollow cash grab. Its poorly written script, lackluster performances, and predictable plot fail to evoke the charm of the original, even if it is occasionally a little funny.
The father-child dynamic that made the first film endearing is absent, replaced by flat humor and underdeveloped characters.
✕ Remove Ads
Compared to the original, audiences were disappointed by the lack of continuity and fresh ideas. Jingle All The Way 2 is a forgettable sequel that fails to live up to its predecessor, earning its place among the worst holiday films. It serves as a reminder that nostalgia alone cannot salvage a poorly executed concept. However, because it does illicit a few laughs, it is not further up the list.
7 Star Wars Holiday Special
Almost So Awful That It Is Good
The Star Wars Holiday Special PGAdventureComedyFamilyMusicalSci-Fi
Director Steve Binder , David Acomba Release Date November 17, 1978 Writers Rod Warren , Bruce Vilanch , Pat Proft , Leonard Ripps , Mitzie Welch Cast Mark Hamill , Harrison Ford , Carrie Fisher , Anthony Daniels , Peter Mayhew , James Earl Jones Runtime 97 minutes Main Genre Adventure Expand
Perhaps the most infamous entry on this list, the Star Wars Holiday Special is notorious for its poor production quality and awkward humor. Released in 1978, the TV special follows beloved Star Wars characters celebrating Life Day, a Wookiee holiday. However, the disjointed mix of musical numbers, comedy sketches, and promotional segments fails to deliver a cohesive story.
… its legacy as a hilarious failure makes it at least worth a single watch for the memes’ sake, something that cannot be said about the majority of the list.
✕ Remove Ads
The tonal mismatch between the epic Star Wars saga and a family-friendly holiday special leaves viewers baffled. Poor acting, lackluster effects, and unrelated segments—like a cooking show—further detract from its appeal. Often regarded as a legendary misstep, the Star Wars Holiday Special remains a cautionary tale of how not to create a holiday film. It’s remembered more for its failure than its content, cementing its spot on this list. However, its legacy as a hilarious failure makes it at least worth a single watch for the memes’ sake, something that cannot be said about the majority of this list.
6 Jack Frost 2: Revenge of the Mutant Killer Snowman
A Film That Takes An Odd Premise Too Far
Jack Frost 2: The Revenge of the Mutant Killer Snowman RFantasyComedyHorror
Jack Frost 2: The Revenge of the Mutant Killer Snowman follows the sheriff and his deputies from the first film as they vacation in the Caribbean. However, they face a revived snowman with enhanced powers seeking revenge, capable of staying frozen in tropical climates.
Director Michael Cooney Release Date November 21, 2000 Cast Christopher Allport , Scott MacDonald , David Allen Brooks , Sean Patrick Murphy , Melanie Good , Tai Bennett , Jennifer Lyons , Shonda Farr , Doug Jones , Ian Abercrombie , Ray Cooney , Eileen Seeley , Chip Heller , Marsha Clark , Stephanie Chao Runtime 91 minutes Character(s) Sam Tiler , Jack Frost (voice) , Agent Manners , Captain Fun , Sarah , Bobby , Rose , Ashlea , Dave , Psychiatrist , Colonel Hickering , Anne Tiler , Joe , Marla , Cindy YouTube Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QWwJm5CVvIM Expand
✕ Remove Ads
Jack Frost 2 takes the original’s absurd premise to even greater extremes, but the result is a disjointed horror-comedy that fails to entertain. The low-budget production features laughably bad special effects and campy acting, making it difficult to take seriously. The humor relies heavily on crude jokes and slapstick, alienating viewers rather than engaging them, which is not a great sign for a Christmas movie. Attempts to merge festive themes with horror elements feel forced and incoherent, resulting in a forgettable and unsuccessful sequel – panned by critics and holding a rare 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
Additionally, the plot lacks depth and originality, making the storyline predictable and uninspiring. The characters are one-dimensional and fail to elicit any emotional investment, further diminishing the film’s impact. Jack Frost 2 is a prime example of a poorly executed concept, earning its place among the worst holiday films. Even fans of campy horror will struggle to find redeeming qualities in this misguided attempt at holiday entertainment, but it could be a lot worse, as evident by later films on this list.
✕ Remove Ads
5 Bad Santa 2
A Poor Retread Of The Original Film
Bad Santa 2 RComedyCrimeDocumentary
Where to Watch
- stream
- rent
- buy
Not available
Not available
Not available
*Availability in US Director Mark Waters Release Date November 23, 2016 Writers Johnny Rosenthal , Shauna Cross , Glenn Ficarra , John Requa Cast Tony Cox , Billy Bob Thornton , Jeff Skowron , Ryan Hansen , Jenny Zigrino , Christina Hendricks , Kathy Bates , Brett Kelly Runtime 92minutes Studio(s) MiraMax Distributor(s) MiraMax , Entertainment One prequel(s) Bad Santa Budget $26 million Expand
Bad Santa 2 tries to replicate the dark humor of its predecessor but fails spectacularly. Billy Bob Thornton reprises his role as Willie T. Soke, the cynical mall Santa, but the film lacks the originality and sharp wit that made the first Bad Santa memorable. Instead, it leans on crass humor and repetitive gags. As such, it fails to introduce new comedic elements or develop its characters further.
Related Bad Santa 2 Review
Bad Santa 2 is another late comedy sequel that fails to catch lightning in a bottle again with a poor script and weak characters.
Posts
✕ Remove Ads
The supporting cast struggles to match the energy of the original, and the plot feels thin and uninspired. Attempts to balance irreverent humor with heartfelt moments fall flat, leaving the film disjointed. Critics and audiences were underwhelmed, and the sequel does little to justify its existence. Bad Santa 2 remains a cautionary tale of how sequels can tarnish the legacy of beloved originals, earning its spot among the worst Christmas movies. However, it has a couple of funny moments, which is better than later films on this list have to offer.
4 Black Christmas (2019)
An Uninspired Remake
Black Christmas PG-13HorrorMysteryThriller
Where to Watch
- stream
- rent
- buy
Not available
Not available
Not available
*Availability in US Director Sophia Takal Release Date December 13, 2019 Writers Sophia Takal , April Wolfe Cast Imogen Poots , Aleyse Shannon , Lily Donoghue , Brittany O’Grady , Caleb Eberhardt , Cary Elwes , Simon Mead , Madeleine Adams , Nathalie Morris , Ben Black , Zoe Robins , Ryan McIntyre , Mark Neilson , Lucy Currey , Jonny McBride Runtime 92 Minutes Studio(s) Film Funding Ltd. , Vision IV , Canadian Film Development Corporation , Famous Players Character(s) Riley Stone , Kris Waterson , Marty Coolidge , Jesse Bolton-Sinclair , Landon , Professor Gelson , Nate , Helena Ritterhouse , Fran Abrams , Phil McIllaney , Oona Apteao , Brian Huntley , Gil O’Leary , Lindsay Helms , Black Mask Franchise(s) Black Christmas Budget $686,000 Main Genre Horror Expand
This remake of the classic horror film Black Christmas fails to balance festive themes with genuine scares. While the original holds a place in horror history, the 2019 version relies on clichéd jump scares and shallow character development. The plot attempts to update the story for contemporary audiences but feels derivative and uninspired.
✕ Remove Ads
The film is lacking in originality and suspense, resulting in a lukewarm reception.
The holiday elements feel forced, and the twists lack impact. The film is lacking in originality and suspense, resulting in a lukewarm 40% critic and 31% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Black Christmas (2019) fails to distinguish itself from other horror remakes, solidifying its position among the worst Christmas movies for its inability to honor or innovate the original. While some might appreciate its attempt to address modern themes, the execution leaves much to be desired, making it one of the least engaging holiday horrors.
3 A Christmas Story 2
An Inferior Follow-up
Your Rating
10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10
Your comment has not been saved
A Christmas Story 2 PG Director Brian Levant Release Date September 6, 2012 Writers Jean Shepherd , Nat Mauldin Cast Daniel Stern , Braeden Lemasters , Stacey Travis , Valin Shinyei , Gerard Plunkett , David Michael Paul Runtime 86 minutes
✕ Remove Ads
A Christmas Story 2 attempts to continue the beloved adventures of Ralphie Parker as a young adult but significantly lacks the charm and humor that made the original film a holiday classic. The sequel struggles with a convoluted plot that feels overcomplicated and fails to maintain the simple, heartfelt narrative that audiences cherished. Additionally, the characters are portrayed as one-dimensional, lacking the fun and relatability that made them memorable in the first movie. For many, this made the film feel uninspired and entirely unnecessary, as it does not offer any fresh perspectives or meaningful developments for Ralphie’s character.
While the original A Christmas Story captured the nostalgia and whimsy of childhood Christmases, A Christmas Story 2 feels forced and disconnected from its predecessor, unable to evoke the same sense of warmth and magic. The sequel’s attempts to build on the original’s legacy fall flat, as it fails to resonate emotionally with both critics and fans alike. Many panned the film for its inability to recreate the authentic, heartwarming moments that made the first movie so relatable and beloved.
✕ Remove Ads
A Christmas Story 2 not only falls short of delivering an engaging story but also tarnishes the legacy of a cherished classic, earning its spot as one of the worst Christmas movies ever made. Its overreliance of predictable scenarios, combined with a lack of original storytelling, make it a disappointing and forgettable follow-up. The film’s inability to honor the spirit of the original and its failure to offer anything new or exciting ultimately leave audiences feeling let down, reinforcing its reputation as a misguided attempt to capitalize on a successful franchise.
2 The Nutcracker (2010)
The Blandest Christmas Movie Ever Made
The Nutcracker: The Untold Story PGFamilyActionFantasy
Director Andrey Konchalovskiy Release Date November 24, 2010 Writers Andrey Knochalovskiy , Chris Solimine Cast Richard Philipps , Fernanda Dorogi , Kriszta Dorogi , Dániel Mogács , Elle Fanning , Stuart Hopps , Aaron Michael Drozin , Nathan Lane Runtime 110 Minutes Studio(s) Vnesheconombank , Nutcracker Holdings , HCC Media Group , Russian Roulette Ltd. Budget 90000000.0 Main Genre Family Expand
✕ Remove Ads
This 2010 adaptation of The Nutcracker attempts to modernize the classic ballet but falls short in nearly every aspect. The lack of visual flair, lifeless performances, and disjointed narrative fail to capture the magic and grandeur of the original. Overuse of CGI and poorly executed choreography alienate both ballet enthusiasts and general audiences. Critics lambasted the film for its inability to honor the essence of the beloved story.
The Nutcracker (2010) is a disappointing adaptation that solidifies its place among the least successful Christmas movies for failing to evoke the artistry of the original play. Its inability to connect with audiences leaves it adrift in the realm of forgotten adaptations. While many of the bad films on this list are memorable for how bad they are, The Nutcracker is simply forgettable—one of the worst things a film can be.
1 Home Sweet Home Alone
A Prime Example Of How To Squander A Legacy
Home Sweet Home Alone PGFamilyComedyAction
Where to Watch
- stream
- rent
- buy
Not available
Not available
Not available
*Availability in US Director Dan Mazer Release Date November 12, 2021 Writers Mikey Day , Streeter Seidell , John Hughes Cast Rob Delaney , Chris Parnell , Ally Maki , Pete Holmes , Andy Daly , Aisling Bea , Timothy Simons , Mikey Day , Ellie Kemper , Kenan Thompson , Archie Yates Runtime 93minutes Studio(s) Disney Distributor(s) Disney Budget $28 million prequel(s) Home Alone , Home Alone 2: Lost in New York , Home Alone 3 , Home Alone 4 Expand
✕ Remove Ads
At the top of this list is Home Sweet Home Alone, a sequel that fails spectacularly to live up to the rest of the Home Alone films. Starring a new cast and following a recycled premise, the film lacks the charm, excitement, and warmth that made the originals a classic. Home Alone and its sequel are absolutely phenomenal classic films. 3 takes the series in a new, yet not-so-bad direction, whereas 4 is heartwarming and underrated, but made the mistake of trying to recast Kevin. 5 continued by being decent, but nothing special.
By contrast, this film was simultaneously mediocre, repetitive, and a total refutation of what made the original so charming. Home Sweet Home Alone‘s characters are uniformly unlikable, its story derivative, and its execution shoddy. This resulted in near-total critical and audience condemnation, evidenced by Rotten Tomatoes scores of 15% and 13%, respectively. While the rest of the films on this list are boring or poorly made, this film is both. Consequently, Home Sweet Home Alone completely deserves the title of the worst Christmas movie of all time.
✕ Remove Ads