The movies of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and other films based on Marvel properties have been known to occasionally cast the wrong actor as a major antagonist. Since the beginning of the MCU’s movie timeline, the franchise has introduced some truly outstanding antagonists into live-action. Adapting characters from the pages of Marvel Comics isn’t always an easy task, however, as getting them just right requires careful consideration and, often, clever casting choices.
In both the Marvel movies of the MCU and outside the franchise, the wrong actors are sometimes chosen to play a villain. Sometimes this is the result of a creative risk not paying off, and others it’s just an apparent miscalculation. Whether the actor in question doesn’t seem to understand the source material or just doesn’t look at all right for the role, here are the 10 worst villain castings in the history of Marvel movies, ranked.
10
Jude Law As Yon-Rogg
First Appearance: Captain Marvel (2019)
Close
The MCU has had some great villain introductions, but its track record with twist reveals is not particularly impressive. Such was the cast with 2019’s Captain Marvel, in which the film’s main villain, Yon-Rogg, was played by Jude Law. For the movie’s first act, Yon-Rogg is presented as Carol Danvers’ Kree mentor, though Law’s casting in the role inadvertently gave his true nature away before the actual reveal.
Though Jude Law has proven himself an incredibly capable actor, his characterization of Yon-Rogg presented issues. The actor’s approach to the character was far too slippery and untrustworthy to be seen as a true mentor, and he was not at all military enough to play a respected Kree soldier. Law’s features and diction were at odds with playing the ruthless and conniving villain, highlighting exactly why he wasn’t right for the role.
9
Christian Bale As Gorr The God Butcher
First Appearance: Thor: Love and Thunder (2022)
Close
By far the most exciting addition to Thor: Love and Thunder’s cast was that of Christian Bale as Gorr the God Butcher. An actor as acclaimed as Bale playing a villain as powerful as Gorr seemed to be a formula for certain success, but his casting actually turned out to be a poor choice.
Taika Waititi’s direction saw Love and Thunder take a decidedly unserious tone. Bale being a largely serious actor made him seem incredibly out of place in the role of Gorr, and though his performance itself was good, he just didn’t quite fit among the more colorful scenery of Waititi’s movie. On paper, Bale should have been perfect as Gorr, but in practice, his casting was a major misstep.
8
Mads Mikkelsen As Kaecilius
First Appearance: Doctor Strange (2016)
Close
2016’s Doctor Strange formally introduced magic to the MCU, offering an entirely new aspect to the franchise by exploring its titular hero and his origins. The movie’s villain, Kaecilius, was once a fellow sorcerer of Kamar-Taj, though having been corrupted by forbidden power, acted instead as a servant of Dormammu. With Mads Mikkelsen cast as Kaecilius, the actor’s talent would seem to have been a great fit for Doctor Strange alongside Benedict Cumberbatch and Tilda Swinton.
Ultimately, Mikkelsen’s casting left much to be desired. Though the script was undoubtedly part of the issue, Mikkelsen’s performance in the role lacked his usual sly charm, and Kaecilius fell incredibly flat. As a result, what should have been Mikkelsen’s triumphant MCU debut was instead one of the franchise’s most forgettable villain performances, wasting an excellent actor in entirely the wrong role.
7
Christopher Eccleston As Malekith
First Appearance: Thor: The Dark World (2013)
Close
Appearing in 2013’s Thor: The Dark World, Christopher Eccleston being cast as Malekith the Accursed is often considered one of the worst castings in Marvel movies. Malekith is often thought to be the MCU’s least memorable villain, which is in part due to Eccleston’s underwhelming performance in the role. The Dark Elf antagonist proved to be one of the blandest and most formulaic characters in the MCU, and Eccleston’s later comments about filming highlight a potential explanation for this.
Admitting his regrets about the MCU, Eccleston claimed to have been misled about the amount of make-up required for the role (via Digital Spy), which may have also led to complications regarding his performance as the character. Though Thor: The Dark World’s script was surely partly to blame, Malekith was ultimately played by the wrong actor.
6
Oscar Isaac As Apocalypse
First Appearance: X-Men: Apocalypse (2016)
Close
Of all the characters introduced in Fox’s X-Men movies, few wasted an actor’s talents as blatantly as Apocalypse. Introduced in 2016’s X-Men: Apocalypse, the mutant antagonist was played by Oscar Isaac, fresh from his appearance in Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Having also earned critical acclaim for his roles in Inside Llewyn Davis and Ex Machina, Isaac seemed a promising choice for the role.
Despite having a broad range of acting ability, Oscar Isaac’s Apocalypse garnered a lackluster reception. The movie’s script made him an incredibly generic villain, and being concealed under layers of makeup and prosthetics did nothing to allow Isaac to communicate any subtleties in his performance. It’s clear that the role offered very little to a performer of Oscar Isaac’s skill set, and for all the hype surrounding his casting, he proved to have been a bad choice for the part.
5
Tim Roth As Emil Blonsky
First Appearance: The Incredible Hulk (2008)
Close
As one of the earliest MCU movies, it’s clear that The Incredible Hulk got some things wrong. One of these was casting Tim Roth as its villain, as despite his talent, he never should have been brought in to play Emil Blonsky. Roth’s role in the movie was as a renowned mercenary who later undergoes an experimental procedure and transforms into the Abomination, a behemoth with all the powers of the Hulk.
Roth’s overcooked accent was out of place in the movie, and the relatively small Roth was not particularly believable as the supposedly intimidating and violent Blonsky, as he appears a far more devious character than he does a fear-inspiring brute. Tim Roth’s casting was a particularly strange decision, as for all his skill, there are very few ways in which he seems to fit the part he was hired to play.
4
Vinnie Jones As The Juggernaut
First Appearance: X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
Close
Of all the actors cast in X-Men: The Last Stand, one in particular stands out as an especially poor choice. Vinnie Jones appears as the Juggernaut in the movie, albeit in a relatively minor role. Despite being one of Magneto’s closest allies in the film, Juggernaut’s role is thankfully limited, as Jones’ performance makes it difficult to watch at times.
Though Vinnie Jones might seem on some level to be a good fit for the role, he simply wasn’t. This is largely down to his incredibly limited acting ability, particularly in such a high-concept comic book movie. Jones’ hammy delivery of his few lines was poor enough that his casting lives on in infamy as one of the worst in the history of Marvel movies, going some way to highlighting why he was entirely the wrong choice for The Last Stand’s Juggernaut.
3
Jared Leto As Morbius
First Appearance: Morbius (2022)
Close
Jared Leto might be an acclaimed actor, but the decision to have him lead the cast of Morbius remains a baffling choice. Leto was cast as the titular doctor, who turns to vampirism to resolve the congenital blood illness that has defined much of his life. However, his casting was ultimately a poor decision, as the combination of Leto’s acting and Morbius’ script turned the movie into little more than a joke.
Leto’s over-serious approach to many of his roles is often the source of criticism, particularly after his controversial antics on the set of Suicide Squad. Morbius saw Leto throw himself wholeheartedly into an incredibly poor script, attempting to sell the CGI-laden story with some authenticity in a way that only made it seem worse. Leto’s apparent unawareness of Morbius’ poor quality only made the movie seem even sillier, proving that he was not the right choice for the role.
2
Topher Grace As Venom
First Appearance: Spider-Man 3 (2007)
Close
The third and final film in Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy, Spider-Man 3, is often considered the worst by a significant margin. One of the major criticisms leveled at the film was the inclusion of three separate villains, including Venom. However, the decision to cast Topher Grace in the role was arguably far worse, as he was a truly terrible fit for the character.
Grace himself has since acknowledged that he was a poor choice for the role, poking fun at his casting. Though he delivered a valiant effort to make Eddie Brock his own, Grace’s style was not at all right for the character, making Spider-Man 3’s Venom seem particularly inaccurate compared to the movie’s other comic book adaptations. For all of Topher Grace’s acting talent, he simply was a terrible choice to play Venom in almost every way.
1
Mickey Rourke As Whiplash
First Appearance: Iron Man 2 (2010)
Close
Yet another actor to earn significant acclaim only to prove himself a poor fit for the superhero genre, Mickey Rourke made his MCU debut in Iron Man 2 as Ivan Vanko. A Russian with a desire for revenge on the Stark family, Vanko creates himself a suit, becoming the villain Whiplash and publicly attacking Tony Stark before joining forces with Justin Hammer. Unfortunately, Rourke’s role remains regarded as one of the franchise’s missed opportunities.
Rourke’s unconvincing accent is incredibly distracting, and his acting choices combine with his limited screentime to make Vanko a clear weak link in Iron Man 2’s otherwise excellent cast. The actor’s later comments about his time in the MCU also suggest he was dissatisfied with the decisions Marvel made regarding his character, implying there were conflicting visions for how Whiplash’s story should have been conveyed. Based on all of this, Mickey Rourke was not the right choice to play the Iron Man 2 antagonist in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
Marvel Cinematic Universe
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is a multimedia superhero franchise that began in 2008 with Paramount’s Iron Man starring Robert Downey Jr. The franchise quickly grew in popularity, with Disney eventually buying out Marvel Entertainment in 2009. The MCU consists of dozens of movies and TV shows, most notably Avengers: Endgame, WandaVision, and Loki.
Upcoming MCU Movies
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
Captain America: Brave New World
Release Date
February 14, 2025
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
Thunderbolts*
Release Date
May 2, 2025
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
The Fantastic Four: First Steps
Release Date
July 25, 2025
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
Avengers: Doomsday (2026)
Release Date
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
Spider-Man Homecoming 4
Release Date
July 24, 2026
-
Your changes have been saved
Email is sent
Email has already been sent
My List
My Favorite Movies
My WatchlistSuccess!
Avengers: Secret Wars
Release Date
May 7, 2027
