Robert Mitchum’s 10 Best Western Movies, Ranked

While he’s best known for his work in film noir, Robert Mitchum starred in over 30 movies in the Western genre as well. Called the “soul of film noir” by Roger Ebert, Mitchum is famous for his iconic villain roles in the ’50s and the ’60s. His work in noir as the classic anti-hero laid the foundation for many of the famous modern antagonistic characters of the genre. However, Mitchum’s superior range as an actor helped him smoothly transition from the suave and stylized villainous roles in film noir to more rough-around-the-edges and dramatized roles.

✕ Remove Ads

As is seen in Western flicks like El Dorado, which is one of the actor’s most famous films ever, and The Tombstones, where Mitchum serves as a narrator off-screen. Mitchum appears beside John Wayne in El Dorado, the latter having replaced the former in an older film after Mitchum was fired from Blood Alley.Mitchum often adopts a likable and charismatic persona in his Western films, usually playing smooth-talking characters who can command situations yet are just as morally gray as his noir characters.

10 Man With The Gun (1955)

Directed By Richard Wilson

Robert Mitchum in Man with the Gun

✕ Remove Ads

Mitchum plays a notorious town-tamer in Man with the Gun. His character, Clint Tollinger, goes to Sheridan City in search of a woman and is inevitably hired by the locals to take care of their troubles, seeing his expertise with guns. The townspeople are being tormented by the gunmen of a local rancher and pay Tollinger a considerable sum of money to deal with this rancher because the local law enforcement doesn’t want to antagonize him.

Kurt Russell's Wyatt with a shotgun and Powers Boothe as Curly Bill Related Tombstone’s Most Outrageous Shootout Scene Actually Happened

One Tombstone gunfight features a moment so ludicrous it feels like it comes right out of an action movie – but it actually happened in real life.

1

Thematically, Man with the Gun explores the idea of how violence begets violence; at some point, Tollinger himself becomes a problem for the residents. He considers himself above the law, and thanks to Mitchum’s penchant for playing immoral protagonists, Tollinger’s narrative role reversal is not only believable but an important device for the film to underscore its message. Being a pretty formulaic Western, however, there’s a distinct lack of self-awareness despite the themes of the film, as it creates spectacle out of the violence.

✕ Remove Ads

9 The Wrath Of God (1972)

Directed By Ralph Nelson

01429013_poster_w780.jpg

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10

Your comment has not been saved

The Wrath of God PGAdventureDramaWestern

The Wrath of God is a 1972 film set in the 1920s, featuring a group of foreigners captured by a South American military faction. They are promised potential freedom in exchange for overthrowing the area’s deranged military commander.

Director Ralph Nelson Release Date July 14, 1972 Writers Jack Higgins Cast Frank Langella , Robert Mitchum , Rita Hayworth , John Colicos , Victor Buono , Ken Hutchison , Paula Pritchett , Gregory Sierra , Frank Ramírez , Enrique Lucero , Jorge Russek , Chano Urueta , José Luis Parades , Aurora Clavel , Victor Eberg , Pancho Córdova , Guillermo Hernández Runtime 111 minutes Expand

The Wrath of God features Mitchum as a gun-slinging priest who fights off corrupt state officials after being spared himself in the process of trying to protect a woman in danger. For fans of the Western genre who enjoy the stylized violent sequences, it is an entertaining film. Mitchum is joined by other acting icons like Frank Langella and Rita Hayworth, portraying a character who is again not the picture of absolute integrity.

The Wrath of God
is Rita Hayworth’s last on-screen appearance.

✕ Remove Ads

However, if the violence and the lawlessness aren’t appealing to a viewer, The Wrath of God isn’t an engaging watch because it is set in a period of American history that’s not contextualized within the film itself. Because of this, the first half especially suffers from almost incoherent plot progression. Its saving grace, which does make the film worth watching, is Mitchum’s acting, especially his stylish dialogue delivery.

See also  Ali Vitali Ethnicity, What is Ali Vitali's Ethnicity?

8 The Wonderful Country (1959)

Directed By Robert Parrish

01428659_poster_w780.jpg

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10

Your comment has not been saved

The Wonderful Country Western

The Wonderful Country follows Martin Brady, who, after fleeing to Mexico for revenge, is drawn back to Texas for an arms deal. As complications arise, including a broken leg and a stolen gun shipment, he navigates tensions between Mexican strongman Cipriano Castro, an American army major, and the Texas Rangers.

Director Robert Parrish Release Date October 21, 1959 Writers Robert Ardrey Cast Julie London , Robert Mitchum , Gary Merrill , Albert Dekker , Pedro Armendáriz , Jack Oakie , Charles McGraw , Anthony Caruso , Mike Kellin , Víctor Manuel Mendoza , Jay Novello , John Banner , Max Slaten , Margarito Luna , Joe Haworth , Tom Lea , Chuck Roberson , Claudio Brook , Chester Hayes , Victoria Horne , Leroy ‘Satchel’ Paige Runtime 98 minutes Expand

✕ Remove Ads

In The Wonderful Country, Mitchum has an off-putting Mexican accent that’s difficult to overlook. However, if one is willing to accept the flaw and give the film their time, they’ll be in for a wild ride between Mexico and the United States. Loosely based on Tom Lea’s novel of the same name, The Wonderful Country follows gunslinger Brady as he goes to secure an arms deal in the U.S., his first time in the country since he fled to Mexico after becoming a fugitive of the law for avenging his father’s murder.

A classic Western, The Wonderful Country has a good mix of romance, thrills, and action, featuring an illicit affair and a series of unfair accusations hurled at the protagonist which make him an outlaw in both countries. The final 15 minutes of the film is an action-heavy chase sequence that concludes with a wistful walk into the horizon as Mitchum heads back towards the U.S., with hopes for the future.

7 Bandit! (1956)

Directed By Richard Fleischer

Robert Mitchum in Bandit!
✕ Remove Ads

Also known as Bandido!, Bandit! is set in the temporal landscape of the Mexican Revolution. Mitchum’s character Wilson is an American mercenary looking to profit off the revolution by working for a rebel leader to hijack an arms deal. Despite a secondary plot of romance buoyed by the gracious presence of Ursula Theiss as Wilson’s love interest, Bandit! often meanders in between action sequences, which are the highlights of the film.

An exciting jailbreak sequence and a thrilling climactic confrontation between the rebels and the “Regulares” stand out from the rest of the set pieces in Bandit! However, the film’s strongest suit is the sleazy charisma of Mitchum’s persona, who nonchalantly throws grenades and operates heavy machinery in the fights to survive the action. Bandit! almost seems to rely on Mitchum’s charms as an actor to engage the audience, as the plot is quite predictable.

✕ Remove Ads

6 Rachel And The Stranger (1948)

Directed By Norman Foster

Robert Mitchum and Loretta Young in Rachel and the Stranger

Starring opposite Loretta Young, who plays the titular Rachel, Mitchum offers a performance of pure laidback charisma in Rachel and the Stranger. A mixture of romance and Western, the film is strengthened by borrowing traits from both genres. While it has a typical resolution, Rachel and the Stranger initially upends romantic traditions by using the cynicism of Westerns, to challenge the romanticization of servile womanhood in marriage one might find in romantic films released even five decades since it came out.

Imagery-from-The-Grey-Fox-and-The-Power-of-the-Dog Related 10 Non-Violent Westerns That Are Still Fantastic

Though the Western genre is well known for including many violent scenes, there are many fantastic films that take a non-violent approach.

✕ Remove Ads

Mitchum isn’t often seen doing this in his films, so when he sings in Rachel and the Stranger, it’s a sight to behold and a treat for ears. His beautiful voice brings life to the melancholic and hopeful lyrics of his songs. The love triangle is completed by William Holden, playing one of his least likable characters ever. His antagonistic persona clashes well with the casualness Mitchum brings to the film as they both vie for the woman’s love, who is unfortunately eventually sidelined in a disappointingly conventional ending.

See also  Hyun Jin Ryu Injury Update, What Happened to Hyun Jin Ryu?

5 Track Of The Cat (1954)

Directed By William A. Welman

01438610_poster_w780.jpg

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Track of the Cat NRDramaWestern

Track of the Cat is a 1954 film set on a mountain valley ranch near Aspen. It explores complex family dynamics amidst the season’s first snowstorm, while the characters face the threat of a mythical panther preying on their cattle.

Director William A. Wellman Release Date November 19, 1954 Writers A.I. Bezzerides Cast Diana Lynn , Robert Mitchum , Tab Hunter , Teresa Wright , Beulah Bondi , Philip Tonge , William Hopper , Carl Switzer Runtime 102 minutes

✕ Remove Ads

Walter Van Tilburg Clark’s novel of the same name was adapted by director William A. Welman for his film Track of the Cat, in which Mitchum plays the middle brother of a trio of sons in a family of bitter people who can’t stop verbally abusing each other out of suspicion of their intentions. Meanwhile, Mitchum’s character leaves the family in their secure spot to go hunt down a panther who seems to be terrorizing the area and poses a danger to all of them.

Track of the Cat is a unique Western in that it’s divided into two parts — an adventurous hunt and a melodramatic family squabble. However, despite the hunt for the dangerous black panther being exciting in its own way, Mitchum feels underutilized, as his acting chops would really shine in the scenes of familial tension.

4 Blood on the Moon (1948)

Directed By Robert Wise

Blood On The Moon (1948) - Poster

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Blood On The Moon WesternDramaRomance

In this gritty Western noir, a drifter named Jim Garry gets caught in the middle of a deadly feud between homesteaders and cattle ranchers in postwar Wyoming. Initially hired by his old friend to help in a deceptive scheme against the settlers, Garry’s conscience is awakened by romance and the brutal reality of this war close to home. As the tensions escalate into violence, Garry must choose a side, inevitably leading to a bloody showdown.

Director Robert Wise Release Date November 21, 1948 Studio(s) RKO Pictures Distributor(s) RKO Radio Pictures Writers Lillie Hayward Cast Robert Mitchum , Barbara Bel Geddes , Robert Preston , Walter Brennan Runtime 88 minutes Expand

✕ Remove Ads

Blood on the Moon constitutes another mixture of genres, allowing Mitchum to bring his A-game when this Western has noir sensibilities in its narrative. Like a classic Western, the backdrop of Blood on the Moon is of vast expanses with no life in sight, peppered by settlements where humanity isn’t thriving, just surviving, motivated by personal wants and needs.

Westerns very commonly focus on the darker sides of humanity, highlighting how greed gets in the way of creating community. However, Blood on the Moon is particularly cynical about people, with its complex dramatic turns being based on people’s cunning. Unlike the roles Mitchum became famous for playing in noir films, he plays the most straightforward, morally upright man in Blood on the Moon. The reactions he prompts from people demonstrate how unrelenting conditions make humans untrusting and selfish.

✕ Remove Ads

3 Pursued (1947)

Directed By Raoul Walsh

Robert Mitchum in Pursued

Raoul Walsh created another melodramatic Western with noir elements in Pursued. The plot is somewhat convoluted, with almost too many twists. However, due to the pacing, and Mitchum’s masterful acting as the protagonist haunted by a forgotten past, it profits from the complexity of the plot. Expansively covering the events of Mitchum’s character’s life, Pursued paints a picture of a man whose fortune often betrays him, albeit favoring him in one-on-one confrontations which he always survives.

See also  Who are Mia Kirshner Parents? Meet Sheldon Kirshner and Etti Kirshner

✕ Remove Ads

Mitchum’s presence as the misunderstood and mistreated man who only wants to marry the love of his life is the primary emotional hook of Pursued. Everything else is just reactions he elicits due to inheriting a dark past that he had no hand in creating. The moral grayness of everyone around him drives the film forward to the action-heavy climax that ultimately comes down to the characters’ emotional states of mind in its resolution.

2 The Lusty Men (1952)

Directed By Nicholas Ray

Robert Mitchum and Susan Hayward in The Lusty Men

The typical macho attitude one associates with rodeos, who are often the heroes of Westerns, is severely challenged in The Lusty Men, adapted from Claude Stanush’s novel of the same name. Mitchum plays a retired rodeo in The Lusty Men, who decides to train another willing man in the art of rodeo as a means to make money.

✕ Remove Ads

Sharon Stone The Quick and The Dead Related 10 Great Westerns With Women In Leading Roles

Traditionally, the Western genre has been dominated by male actors, but there are many top-tier Westerns with a woman in the leading role.

4

The Lusty Men never meanders from its path of exposing the fallibility of a person who is driven by fame and pride, employing melodramatic themes of familial distress, growing distrust in people, and illicit proclamations of love. Mitchum’s persona is equally pitiful and charismatic, a fine line he walks in superior fashion, driving the plot forward to a violent ending with his nuanced performance that is antithetical to the young man his character is training.

1 El Dorado (1966)

Directed By Howard Hawks

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

10/10 El Dorado PassedDramaRomanceWestern

In “El Dorado,” veteran gunslinger Cole Thornton is summoned by a wealthy rancher, Bart Jason, to assist in a land dispute. However, upon arriving in the town of El Dorado, Thornton discovers from his old friend, Sheriff J.P. Harrah, that Jason’s true motives are far from just. Determined to prevent unnecessary violence, Thornton joins forces with the sheriff and a young, eager deputy named Mississippi to protect the besieged MacDonald family.

Director Howard Hawks Release Date June 7, 1967 Studio(s) Laurel Productons Distributor(s) Paramount Pictures Writers Leigh Brackett Cast John Wayne , Robert Mitchum , James Caan , Charlene Holt , Paul Fix , Arthur Hunnicutt , Michele Carey Runtime 126 Minutes Expand

✕ Remove Ads

One of Mitchum’s most famous films, and his first appearance beside John Wayne, El Dorado is as formulaic as an action-heavy Western gets — but that’s its biggest strength. A masterful use of oft-seen Western elements like jaded leading men, unruly criminals difficult to subdue, shootouts, and an injured, but charismatic Wayne, ensures it’s a fun ride from start to finish. Mitchum and Wayne have a rather entertaining fistfight, where the former’s character is drunk and being persuaded by the latter’s character to get sober.

El Dorado
is a remake of
Rio Bravo
, which was also directed by Howard Hawks.

✕ Remove Ads

Robert Mitchum plays a supporting role in El Dorado with significantly less screen time than Wayne, but whenever he’s on the screen, his ability to blend charm with dysfunction shines through. Playing a sheriff who’s considerably incompetent, Mitchum creates the space for Wayne to shine as the savior hero. Yet Mitchum’s performance still makes him an unforgettable element of one of the best Westerns made in the ’60s.

Leave a Comment