Batman has one of the most compelling origin stories in comic book history, depicted in a litany of DC movies and series with varying degrees of efficacy. Batman’s backstory is a cornerstone of his mythos, triggering his transformation into the Dark Knight. Throughout the DCU’s history, various adaptations have put their own spin on this defining moment, some staying faithful to the source material while others take creative liberties, which will likely continue into the DCU’s future. As a result, some have been markedly more effective than others.
Batman’s origin story is simple yet powerful. Young Bruce Wayne leaves a theatre with his parents, Thomas and Martha, turning down Crime Alley. A mugger attacks the family, typically stealing Martha’s pearl necklace before shooting the parents. This traumatic event inspires Bruce to dedicate his life to fighting crime. This story has been retold and reimagined countless times in various media, and will likely be a key part in James Gunn’s Batman.
22
Beware The Batman – “Secrets” (2014)
Season 1, Episode 2
Beware The Batman delivered a sleek and modern take on the Dark Knight, but its rendition of his origin story in the episode “Secrets” fell flat. The scene uses creative angles and editing to obscure the grisly detail. However, it feels disconnected, devoid of emotion, and like a perfunctory necessity. While the series excels in depicting Batman’s detective skills and unique rogues’ gallery, its take on his origin is disappointingly soulless, feeling more like a box checked than a meaningful exploration.
21
Batman: Death in the Family (2020)
Animated Interactive Movie
In Batman: Death in the Family, Bruce remembers his parent’s murder while pondering his care for Jason Todd. The scene is told through still images, during which Bruce discusses Zoro with his father. Thomas’s advice that Gotham likely would not accept a masked vigilante is a compelling detail that further ties Batman to his origin. Nevertheless, the scene is brief, serving primarily as an obligatory nod to remind audiences of the parallels between Bruce and Jason’s origins.
20
The Super Powers Team: Galactic Guardians – “The Fear” (1985)
Season 1, Episode 4
Close
Despite its dated animation and storytelling style, the depiction of Batman’s origin in The Super Powers Team: Galactic Guardians is surprisingly effective. The episode “The Fear” delves into Bruce’s trauma, portraying the murder with its full level of emotional weight. The sequence combined a focus on Bruce’s reaction, a few close-ups of a gun and Martha’s handbag, and a well-timed clap of thunder to signal the gunshot. While it may not have the polish of modern adaptations, this version conveys Batman’s origin effectively within the restrictions of 1980s animation.
19
Teen Titans Go! To The Movies (2018)
Teen Titans Go! Spin-Off Movie
Teen Titans Go! To The Movies offers a gleefully silly take on Batman’s origin. The Titans travel to the night of the Waynes’ murder, and intervene, redirecting them away from Crime Alley and down Happy Valley instead. Later, needing to tidy up the timeline, they return, and Robin maniacally pushes the Waynes into Crime Alley and a flurry of off-screen gunfire. It won’t resonate with everyone, but seeing such a sacred moment being lampooned in such a silly way is very fun.
18
Joker (2019)
Directed By Todd Phillips
Close
Todd Phillips’ Joker includes a brief depiction of the Waynes’ murder, tying it to the chaotic uprising sparked by Arthur Fleck’s actions. While the scene is visually striking and connects the Joker to Batman’s origin, it feels tacked on, serving more as fan service than a meaningful addition to the story. It’s such a surprise that it fails to resonate, reducing the Waynes to mere casualties of Gotham’s descent into anarchy. While it’s an interesting twist to connect it with Joker’s rise, it feels like a pointless addition.
17
Justice League Unlimited – “For The Man Who Has Everything” (2004)
Season 1, Episode 2
Close
The Justice League Unlimited episode “For The Man Who Has Everything” briefly touches on Batman’s origin as part of a broader narrative. The depiction is pretty standard and lacks any innovation but is sufficiently effective. It appears in black and white and includes a more dynamic fight between Thomas and his killer, before zooming in on Bruce’s despairing reaction as the gun fires. This rendition likewise feels like a fleeting addition to tie Batman’s origin to Superman’s in the narrative.
16
The Batman – “The Big Chill” (2004)
Season 1, Episode 6
Close
The Batman takes an oblique and expressionist approach to Bruce’s origin in the episode “The Big Chill.” While the series’ child-friendly format limits its emotional intensity, this version effectively expresses the origin story. Bruce remembers his parents’ killer aiming a gun, who transforms into Mister Freeze and freezes a photograph of Thomas and Martha. Although it’s not as detailed or emotionally impactful as other versions, it succeeds in capturing the essence of Bruce’s journey within the constraints of its target audience.
15
Batman: Gotham Knight (2008)
Animated Anthology Movie
Close
The anthology film Batman: Gotham Knight features a fleeting depiction of Bruce’s origin in one of its segments. The scene is beautifully animated but offers little substance. It features just two shots, the Waynes cowering in an alley and a close-up of a revolver firing. It’s a visually impressive reminder of Bruce’s trauma, but its fleeting presence prevents it from making a lasting impact. While the film’s focus is on exploring different facets of Batman’s persona, this version of his origin feels more like an afterthought than a meaningful exploration.
14
Batman: The Doom That Came to Gotham (2023)
Directed By Christopher Berkeley & Sam Liu
This Elseworlds adaptation reimagines Batman’s origin in a Lovecraftian setting, blending gothic horror with classic mythology. The Waynes’ murder is transformed into a harrowing knife fight, after which Bruce’s isolation and despair are truly felt. While the old-timey retelling is fun and atmospheric, it is mostly a fun diversion from the classic origin story. While it’s an intriguing and unique take, it sacrifices emotional depth for stylistic flair, leaving it less noteworthy overall.
13
Batman Forever (1995)
Directed By Joel Schumacher
Close
Batman Forever offers a flashy and stylized version of Bruce’s origin, largely a quick rehash of the depiction in Batman (1989). While visually striking, the scene prioritizes brevity over emotional depth, accentuating the film noir tone even further. It later adds Bruce’s memory of discovering the Batcave, where a single bat flies towards him. The image of the single looming bat is quite unnerving, but not very compelling. Despite its flaws, this version is serviceable and fits the film’s tone, but fails to add anything new.
12
Batman: The Brave and the Bold – “Chill of the Night!” (2010)
Season 2, Episode 11
The Batman: The Brave and the Bold episode “Chill of the Night!” delivers a straightforward rendition of Bruce’s origin. While it’s competently executed, it doesn’t bring anything new to the table. The scene serves its purpose within the episode, and is one of the show’s most attractive scenes, befitting the animation style. However, it lacks the emotional resonance or innovative storytelling that distinguishes other versions. Its faithfulness to the source material is commendable, but it ultimately feels average in comparison.
11
Batman Beyond – “Rebirth” (1999)
Season 1, Episodes 1-2
The futuristic series Batman Beyond introduces a new Batman with his own origin story. After upsetting the Jokerz gang, Terry returns home where he finds his father has been murdered by them. This prompts Terry to agree to take over the mantle as the Batman. What makes this rendition so notable is that it happens during the present, not during a flashback or memory, making it far more gripping. It offers a fresh perspective that expands the legacy of Batman’s origin story.
10
Batman: Bad Blood (2016)
Directed By Jay Olva
Batman: Bad Blood features a chilling nightmare sequence that depicts Bruce’s origin. While not a traditional retelling, the sequence adds a nightmarish intensity that underscores the psychological toll of his trauma. Bruce has a flashback on the infamous night, but after they’re killed, Bruce’s parents claw at him and pull him lunging into a giant puddle. This offers a unique perspective but stops short of being a comprehensive retelling. Its creative approach makes it stand out, but it’s not as definitive as other adaptations.
9
Gotham – “Pilot” (2014)
Season 1, Episode 1
Close
The pilot episode of Gotham delivers a powerful depiction of the Waynes’ murder, setting the stage for the series. The scene’s emotional weight is palpable, and young Bruce’s grief is portrayed convincingly. However, the drawn-out nature of the show’s narrative dilutes the impact of this moment over time. While it’s a strong start, the origin story becomes secondary to the sprawling ensemble cast and numerous subplots, weakening its overall significance.
8
Batman (1989)
Directed By Tim Burton
Close
Tim Burton’s Batman controversially ties the Waynes’ murder to the Joker, deviating from the traditional narrative. While this twist has been debated, the scene itself is pretty quintessential Batman. Its gothic atmosphere, emotional weight, and iconic noir-inspired fashion and lighting make it a standout moment. Despite the changes to the lore, this version captures the essence of Bruce’s transformation into Batman, solidifying its place as a classic retelling and establishing the 1980s/90s era of Batman movie.
7
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns: Part One (2012)
Directed By Jay Olva
The animated adaptation of The Dark Knight Returns delivers a bleak and haunting rendition of Bruce’s origin. The stark visuals and sombre tone emphasize the trauma and determination that define Batman. The scene is depicted in a desaturated, sepia black and white, with Matha and Thomas’s crimson blood contrasting drastically. This version stays true to the source material, presenting it with a more mature tone than others in the list and in all its bloodied glory.
6
Batman Vs. Robin (2015)
Directed By Jay Olva
In Batman Vs. Robin, Bruce’s origin is depicted in two parts: a standard flashback and a harrowing moment of introspection. The first part is beautifully animated, depicting the standard story, while the second is a nightmarish vision where Batman sees himself as the killer, suggesting that his vigilante actions have created more criminality that it has solved. This dual approach adds depth and maturity, expanding upon the story for the narrative’s benefit, making it a standout version.
5
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox (2013)
Directed By Jay Olva
Close
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox offers a chilling inversion of Batman’s origin, with young Bruce dying instead of his parents. The result is a terrifying and tragic version of Thomas Wayne as Batman and Martha as the Joker. While it’s more of a novelty than a traditional retelling, its emotional impact and creative twist make it a memorable and thought-provoking take on the story, with a chilling tone that remains with the viewer.
4
Batman Vs. Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)
Directed By Zack Snyder
Close
The opening sequence of Batman Vs. Superman presents Bruce’s origin as a dreamlike montage. The striking visuals and Hans Zimmer’s score create a deeply atmospheric and effective depiction. This version captures the trauma and symbolism of the event, inter-cutting the murder with the Waynes’ funeral, and Bruce discovering the Batcave, making it one of the highlights of the film. While it doesn’t add new narrative elements, its execution is masterful, elevating it above many other adaptations.
3
Batman: Year One (2011)
Directed By Sam Liu & Lauren Montgomery
The animated adaptation of Batman: Year One offers a faithful and visually stunning rendition of Bruce’s origin. The high contrast visuals and tender imagery emphasize the gravity of the event in a genuinely beautiful manner. The stark black and white scene contains many of the classic elements, culminating in a recreation of the iconic Batman: Year One #1 cover. It is the best version of Batman’s origin depicted in a mature animated project.